design::writings
emDesign designwritings photolog portfolio resume genealogy team in training dr leslie project
thoughts and observations about design, information architecture and design history
« The Decline of the Access Guides | Main | IA Is Really A Creative Pursuit »

Wednesday 12|19|01
Info Arch vs. Graphic Design

Gerry McGovern's most recent column decides to pit Information Architecture versus Graphic Design. He obviously does not understand Graphic Design and design training. His arguments assume that the Graphic Designer is purely a purveyor of style and is a graphic artist rather than a problem solver who creates COMMUNICATION solutions appropriate to the medium in which it will be delivered.

Graphic Designers are getting a bad rap across the web and within a lot of communities. The influx of "designers" who spread across the web during the heyday and swathed sites with heavy graphics and inappropriate flash sites have given the field - which concerns itself with creating solutions that most appropriately communicate meaning - a bad name.

The latest Communication Arts issue has an essay by Nancy Nowacek that comes at this Us vs. Them from the point of view of a well trained thoughtful designer. She defines Design to be:

"Design is also understanding cultural signs and human behavior to create resonant, clear, and intuitively usable objects."

This is what Design is about. She also points out that many designers who worked in print, also did signage sytems and environmental spaces, they worked on Annual Reports and a variety of other problems that required careful thought about the problem, the intended communication, the best solution and an understanding of the final presentation medium.

She notes that many of us, in order to continue to grow and work on the interesting projects and to make a difference, have evolved, have changed our titles and pretty much never mention that we are graphic designers. The name, the profession, used be something that she and many of us were proud to tell people. Now we are "Information Designers" or Information Architects" or "UI Designers" but we have dropped the dreaded Graphic because of the negative connotations associated with it by many in the online world.

Many senior designers that I know, have taken their skills in organizing for meaning, in grouping and developing systems and displays, and become Information Architects. The skills are translateable. I am not saying that there aren't a lot of misguided and poorly trained people out there calling themselves "Graphic Designers", but I am asking that we shouldn't all be judged by what a few are doing. I am an Information Architect. I am a Graphic Designer. I use my skills and experience across multiple mediums and have great concern for choosing the appropriate solutions for the medium. There shouldn't be an Us vs. Them. We are Us. We are Them. There are a lot of people I know who feel the same way.

Posted by erin at 12:18 PM | in Criticism

Comments

Gerry's article is pretty poor ("people were upset that I said it is a library. But it is library") in terms of articulating his arguments.

I think he's taking one basic aspect of the graphic design profession (eye-catching visuals for print ads and packaging) and just cutting it off right there. Obviously, there is more that graphic designers have always done - structure information, tell a story, make information usable and useful. The web is no different - the graphic design approach equires taking into account the medium where the artifact will be experienced, be it web, software, subway, CD package, or grocer's freezer.

Posted by Steve Portigal at January 3, 2002 11:56 AM
...................................................

Regarding all the articles by people like Gerry McGovern that have been circulating the past 2 years... Why should those of us who "get it" spend any more time refuting his/their claims and opinions. I say we stop defending and make our point of attack be through our actions of solving problems and creating appropriate solutions in any medium/media we are working in. I believe we will make more progress preaching our cause, educating clients, and defining who we are and what we do by not spending time responding to people like Gerry.

Posted by Jeff Johnson at January 4, 2002 06:19 AM
...................................................

...................................................
Post a comment
Name:


Email Address:


URL:


Comments:


EM Design is home to the resume and portfolio of Erin Malone.
site updated all the dang time! :: copyright 1995-2003 Erin K. Malone
view by category
AIGA
Amazon
AOL
Books
Community
Conference Review
Conferences
Criticism
El Lissitzky
Event
Graphic Design
Herbert Bayer
History
Information Architecture
Interaction Design
Magazines
People
Sites of Note
Techniques
Theory
Timelines
Typography
User Centered Design
William Golden

view by month
May 2003
April 2003
March 2003
February 2003
January 2003
December 2002
November 2002
October 2002
September 2002
August 2002
July 2002
June 2002
May 2002
April 2002
March 2002
February 2002
January 2002
December 2001
November 2001
October 2001
September 2001
August 2001
July 2001
June 2001
May 2001
April 2001
March 2001
February 2001

articles
The Tool Makes the (Wo)man

AIGA Experience Design Summit #5 - Recap

AIGA Experience Design - past, present and future: An interview with Terry Swack and Clement Mok

Summit Beginnings: Saturday

Chicken Run: Summit Closing: Sunday

design history articles
Foreseeing the future: The legacy of Vannevar Bush

Learning from the Powers of Ten


daily reads
XML
Powered by
Movable Type
Independents Day - Celebrating the Independent Web Aortal: The Anti Portal
The Ageless Project