How Many Americans Are Really Infected With the Coronavirus?

Health care reporter Caroline Chen dug into the projections to learn what to make of them. Forecasts are fuzzy, but the takeaway is clear: Stay home.

by Caroline Chen

March 18, 5 a.m. EDT

Series: Coronavirus

Is the United States Prepared for COVID-19?

ProPublica is a nonprofit newsroom that investigates abuses of power. Sign up to receive our biggest stories as soon as they’re published.

There’s a pandemic spreading across the U.S., and amid ongoing struggles to scale up testing, it’s still unclear how many people are actually infected.

In the absence of real numbers, projections have filled the void, and I’ve been struggling as a reporter to know which forecasts to trust. Last week, the Ohio Department of Health said that over 100,000 people were infected, at a time when there were five confirmed cases in the state. Some epidemiology experts critiqued that estimate as too high, and the department’s director later said she was “guesstimating.”

Should reporters second-guess their health department’s figures? When is it safe for me to retweet? I set out to talk to some experts and learned just how fuzzy those forecasts can be. But there are ways we can think about them that help give us more clarity.

Help Us Report On Coronavirus

Are you a public health worker, medical provider, elected official, patient or other COVID-19 expert? Help make sure our journalism is responsible and focused on the right issues.

It’s impossible to know how many people are infected right now. Just know that the number is far higher than the running case count.

It’s easier to do big, sweeping projections on a question like how many people will be infected by the time this is all over and done with. Marc Lipsitch, head of the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health’s Center for Communicable Disease Dynamics, has been running projections to figure out how many adults across the world will be infected before a vaccine hits the market (one won’t be available for at least a year) or herd immunity kicks in — when enough people have developed immunity to the virus, from having caught it, so that it can’t easily be transmitted any more. He concluded that between 20% and 60% of adults worldwide will ultimately get infected. (ProPublica has created a tool based on his models and it’s worth checking out.)

It’s much harder to figure out how many Americans are infected at this very moment. Some states have little information because they’ve barely started testing and don’t know when community transmission began in specific places. Many people with symptoms consistent with COVID-19 were turned away from getting tests.

Caitlin Rivers, a computational epidemiologist at Johns Hopkins Center for Health Security, said she’s “not sure we’re in a place where we’re able to estimate that,” though she’s confident that there are far more infected people than the number of reported cases at this time. Computational epidemiologist Maia Majumder said that without widespread testing, this is a “really challenging question to pin down.”

In short, the best way to actually know is with hard evidence — which means testing. As World Health Organization director general Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus said on Monday: “You cannot fight a fire blindfolded, and we cannot stop this pandemic if we don’t know who is infected. We have a simple message for all countries: Test, test, test.”

Think in orders of magnitude. The numbers are less precise than they seem.

Of course, computational epidemiologists do have ways of coming up with ballpark estimates. I asked the experts to discuss this sentence with me, from a March 14 post about New York City’s looming crisis by a Facebook data scientist:

“We estimate that between 1,281 and 2,280 people are infected as of yesterday.”

That range seems to be both wide yet oddly specific. What is a reader supposed to take away from a sentence like that?

Get Our Top Investigations

Subscribe to the Big Story newsletter.

Email address
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Reporting precise numbers allows epidemiologists to replicate each others’ work; rerunning the same equations and arriving at the same results helps to validate findings. Public health officials also need as much information as possible because it’s helpful for decision-making about preparing hospital beds or closing schools.

My concern, however, is that a sentence like that can give readers a false sense of precision, as if it’s possible to know down to a difference of one or two people. When I asked Rivers what a regular person should take from these counts, she said people should focus on the order of magnitude: “This means there’s a couple of thousand people, it’s not 200 or 4 million. It means we’re in the low thousands.”

“If the forecast doesn’t state its assumptions, I’d be wary,” Majumder said. For example, a popular modeling approach, called the SIR model, assumes that each individual is equally likely to come into contact with any other individual in the population; you don’t have to have a Ph.D. to see how that’s not very realistic.

Majumder also noted that just because someone is good at math doesn’t mean that they’re equipped to do epidemiological forecasting, which comes with its own nuances. “Has the author published epidemiological modeling studies – preferably of other emerging infectious diseases – before in peer-reviewed literature?”

My advice: Check who the numbers are coming from before repeating them.

Don’t get hung up on the specifics. The big picture is clear.

Trying to get clarity on exactly how many people are infected in your city shouldn’t be your goal, if you’re a regular member of the public. Rivers and Majumder agreed on this: There’s no difference in what action you need to take, whether the models say there will be 10,000 or 20,000 infections in your state within a certain number of days or weeks.

There isn’t a single expert I’ve talked to who said case counts won’t continue to soar. There are two reasons for this: As testing becomes more available, cases that already exist will be revealed. Secondly, of course, the virus is continuing to spread. The trends are crystal clear, and the call to action is indisputable. ”If your state has reported community transmission, the message is the same no matter the number of cases: engage in social distancing immediately,” Majumder said.

Read More

Millions of Federal Workers Still Waiting on Work-From-Home Order During Coronavirus Pandemic

Public health experts agree that Americans need to stay home as much as possible, but the Trump administration has not yet issued clear guidance to federal workers.

In some ways, the United States is lucky, because the disease arrived here later than it did in China or Italy. We don’t need to rely on computer models to guess what we have to do. We can look to other countries that have been dealing with the virus longer than us.

Rivers points to some countries in Asia that have taken sweeping measures, including closing schools, testing en masse and even publishing the past whereabouts (without names) of people who tested positive, as in South Korea — from the restaurants people visited to the specific seats they sat in at movie theaters.

“They took these interventions really seriously and were really committed in order to avoid a scenario like Italy,” she said. “That’s really what we should be focusing on as a country.”

For reporters, this means two things: Of course, we should continue to ask public officials to explain where they get their numbers from and run them by experts before publication whenever possible. But more crucially, the press needs to hold those in power accountable for their actions — or lack thereof. While it’s forgivable to put out a bad estimate, it’s unforgivable to not act in the face of a pandemic that is not just at our doorstep, but already inside our house.

Each of us has the power to help flatten the curve.

I’m sure by now you’ve already heard about this notion, which comes with its own hashtag. In a nutshell, to avoid a spike of critical cases that will overload our hospitals, we need to implement mitigation strategies to slow down disease transmission.

For the past week, my email inbox has been a sea of panic. A woman in California wrote that she is the full-time caregiver for her elderly mother and is terrified of infecting her. Should she wear gloves at all times, even to touch the mail? Should she never leave the house? A New England retail worker described her fear while ringing people up all day, but said: “I need the money for my bills. I don’t know what to do.” A hospital administrator trying to secure supplies for her facility told me: “I can’t lose my job. I can’t lose my life insurance. If I die, I need my child taken care of.”

Read More

Are Hospitals Near Me Ready for Coronavirus? Here Are Nine Different Scenarios.

How soon regions run out of hospital beds depends on how fast the novel coronavirus spreads and how many open beds they had to begin with. Here’s a look at the whole country. You can also search for your region.

On Saturday night, after reading too many of these messages in one go, I cried, knowing there was so little I could do to actually help and feeling overwhelmed by how large the problem felt.

But the next morning, I woke up to Berlin-based reporter Kai Kupferschmidt’s suggestion that we all share “positive or practical things” that we’d seen or done, big or small, “to adapt to this new world we find ourselves in.” For the first time in a while, bright spots illuminated my computer screen. A member of my book club emailed everyone offering to help buy food and supplies. Dr. Esther Choo, an associate professor of emergency medicine, tweeted: “Medical students around the country, taken off clinical rotations due to #COVID, have set up babysitting networks to support essential hospital staff.” All these stories cheered me immensely and encouraged me that I didn’t have to sit back helplessly; I could take small actions myself.

When forecast figures are being thrown around — thousands and hundreds of thousands and millions of people — it can be hard for them to feel real. But when I remind myself that all these fearful and anxious and generous and compassionate people are who we’re all fighting for, it’s a no-brainer as to why I should stay at home, even if I am young and healthy.

The curve will certainly rise for the next few weeks. There will be more fear-inducing headlines that give us reason to doubt the level of preparedness. But know that our individual actions — staying home, enabling health care workers by not hoarding supplies like masks, doing what we can to take care of the most vulnerable in our society — can all help flatten that curve. I hope that our collective efforts mean that it will not rise for too long, and it will not be too steep. In the meantime, take care, and be well.

Tell Us More About Coronavirus

Are you a public health worker, medical provider, elected official, patient or other COVID-19 expert? Help make sure our journalism is responsible and focused on the right issues.

 *
A NOTE ABOUT OUR COMMITMENT TO YOUR PRIVACY: We appreciate you sharing your story and we take your privacy seriously. ProPublica is gathering this information for our reporting, not for publication. If you would prefer to get in touch with us another way, send an email to coronavirus@propublica.org, message us on Signal at ‪(201) 701-0850, or visit propublica.org/tips.
What would you like to share with us? What would you like to share with us?  *
I want to provide you with a tip or story idea. I'm willing to answer reporters’ questions if they arise.
What’s your connection to the emerging threat of COVID-19? What’s your connection to the emerging threat of COVID-19? *
I’m a doctor, nurse or other medical provider I’m an emergency response professional I’m a hospital employee I work for a government agency I work in a laboratory I’m an elected official I work in the pharmaceutical/drug industry I work in medical equipment manufacturing or the supply chain I work in public health in another capacity I have personally been affected by COVID-19, or someone I know has been affected. I work in social services I work in or with a school, college or university I attend a school, college or university, or I'm a parent of someone who does
Other
Where do you live? Where do you live?
If you're employed: What sort of work do you do?
Are you currently under quarantine or self-quarantine? Have you been quarantined? Are you currently under quarantine or self-quarantine? Have you been quarantined?
Yes No
Have you lost a job or paycheck for coronavirus-related reasons? Have you lost a job or paycheck for coronavirus-related reasons?
What happened?
Are you expecting to lose income as a result of coronavirus? Are you expecting to lose income as a result of coronavirus?
Yes No
Does your employer offer paid sick leave? Does your employer offer paid sick leave?
Yes No Not applicable
Does your job require meeting people face to face? Does your job require meeting people face to face?
Do you have to visit their homes, and if so, are you still visiting their homes?
How is the coronavirus affecting the communities you serve? We’re particularly interested to hear about your access to and ability to see clients/patients.
Does your job have adequate back-up staffing if you get sick? Does your job have adequate back-up staffing if you get sick?
Do you feel prepared to help your clients get proper treatment/testing for COVID-19? Do you feel prepared to help your clients get proper treatment/testing for COVID-19?
How do you expect the quarantine will affect your life? What, if anything, worries you?
What, if anything, has changed about your workload?
Are you supplied with the resources and gear you need for coronavirus? Are you supplied with the resources and gear you need for coronavirus?
Please explain.
What kind of direction are you getting from your higher-ups about coronavirus?
Who is in charge of your chain of command? What person or agency sets the policies that you follow?
Do you feel prepared to handle calls that involve people who are potentially infected with coronavirus? Do you feel prepared to handle calls that involve people who are potentially infected with coronavirus?
Please explain.
What sort of public health organization do you work with?
What is the name of your health organization?
Do you still work there? Do you still work there?
Has your organization been able to adequately do its part to prepare for COVID-19? Has your organization been able to adequately do its part to prepare for COVID-19?
Why not?
Do you believe you have the supplies you need to respond to COVID-19? Do you believe you have the supplies you need to respond to COVID-19?
What are you missing?
Do you work at a national, state, local or county level? Do you work at a national, state, local or county level?
Which government agency?
Has your agency been able to adequately do its part to prepare the nation for COVID-19? Has your agency been able to adequately do its part to prepare the nation for COVID-19?
Why not?
Does your agency have sufficient staff to prepare for COVD-19? Does your agency have sufficient staff to prepare for COVD-19?
Tell us more about the shortfall.
Have you been adequately trained to respond to COVID-19? Have you been adequately trained to respond to COVID-19?
What training are you lacking?
Does your agency have sufficient equipment to respond to COVID-19? Does your agency have sufficient equipment to respond to COVID-19?
What are you missing?
What is your role? What is your role?
Do you work in a hospital? Do you work in a hospital?
Which hospital?
Where do you work?
Do you live or work in a nursing home? Do you live or work in a nursing home?
Which nursing home?
What is your workplace doing to protect you from infection?
Do you believe these protections are strong enough? Do you believe these protections are strong enough?
Why not?
Do you believe you have the supplies you need to respond to COVID-19? Do you believe you have the supplies you need to respond to COVID-19?
What are you missing?
Do you believe your hospital is prepared for COVID-19 patients? Do you believe your hospital is prepared for COVID-19 patients?
Why not?
Please elaborate.
Which laboratory do you work for?
Has your lab received a CDC test kit? Has your lab received a CDC test kit?
Has your lab been able to validate the test kit? Has your lab been able to validate the test kit?
Has your lab started testing any samples from the public? Has your lab started testing any samples from the public?
Do you believe the CDC test is accurate? Do you believe the CDC test is accurate?
Why not?
Have you had any issues with the N1 assay? Have you had any issues with the N1 assay?
What kind of issues?
Have you had any issues with the N2 assay? Have you had any issues with the N2 assay?
What kind of issues?
Do you have any concerns that you will run out of testing kits? Do you have any concerns that you will run out of testing kits?
Why?
Why not?
Are you attempting to get your own version of the CDC assay validated by the FDA? Are you attempting to get your own version of the CDC assay validated by the FDA?
Is your lab a public health lab? Is your lab a public health lab?
Does your lab have plans to, or has it started to, conduct sentinel surveillance? Does your lab have plans to, or has it started to, conduct sentinel surveillance?
When will you start/did you start? When will you start/did you start?
What is your role in the pharmaceutical industry?
Where do you work?
Is your company developing a vaccine or drug for COVID-19? Is your company developing a vaccine or drug for COVID-19?
When do you think your vaccine or drug will reach the market?
What is the pharmaceutical industry doing to prepare the country for COVID-19?
What is your role in medical equipment manufacturing or supply chain?
Where do you work?
Does your company make or distribute supplies that are required for response to COVID-19? Does your company make or distribute supplies that are required for response to COVID-19?
What do you make?
Do you think the U.S. has sufficient supplies to be prepared for COVID19? Why or why not?
Who has been affected? Who has been affected?
How is this person affected? How is this person affected?
When did you first suspect a diagnosis of COVID-19? When did you first suspect a diagnosis of COVID-19?
What did you do? What did you do?
Which hospital or urgent care clinic did you go to?
What kind of insurance did you or this person have? What kind of insurance did you or this person have?
Are you writing to us about preschool, K-12 or higher education? Are you writing to us about preschool, K-12 or higher education?
What’s the name of your school?
If school has closed, how is instruction still happening? How is this going?
Do you work with students who have special needs, or do you have a student with special needs in your family? Do you work with students who have special needs, or do you have a student with special needs in your family?
Have you received guidance for students with special needs, or do you have a student with special needs in your family? How are school closures affecting these students?
What kind of communication or direction are you receiving from your school about coronavirus precautions?
What happens to other non-teaching staff who aren’t needed during the school closure?
Are school faculty and staff getting paid sick leave? Are school faculty and staff getting paid sick leave?
What is your area of expertise in relation to COVID-19?
What are you worried about? What causes you concern?
Is there anything else we should know? Or anything else we should be thinking about as we report?
ProPublica specializes in investigative and accountability reporting. What story or stories do you think we should pursue?
Are there any public records you would suggest we request?
Are there any documents or other files you think we should see? Upload here or feel free to get in touch via email at coronavirus@propublica.org. If you want a more secure method of communicating, like Signal, just send an email and we’ll provide you that information. Are there any documents or other files you think we should see? Upload here or feel free to get in touch via email at coronavirus@propublica.org. If you want a more secure method of communicating, like Signal, just send an email and we’ll provide you that information.
Upload a file
We may have follow-up questions. What's your phone number?
This isn’t for publication. A reporter may contact you with additional questions.
What's the best way to reach you? What's the best way to reach you?
Email Phone
Other
ProPublica reporters are the only ones reading these submissions. However, we may team up with other news outlets for stories outside of our wheelhouse. Would you be OK with us passing along your tip to a trusted local partner? ProPublica reporters are the only ones reading these submissions. However, we may team up with other news outlets for stories outside of our wheelhouse. Would you be OK with us passing along your tip to a trusted local partner?
Yes No Ask me first
Your phone number
Do you want to be notified when ProPublica publishes big investigations? Do you want to be notified when ProPublica publishes big investigations?  *
Yes No

SPREAD THE WORD

Thank you for sharing with us. Help us reach as many people as possible in order to better understand this topic. We ask for the following information to learn more about who we are reaching and who else we should try to include.

How did you find this form? I saw it on/in: How did you find this form? I saw it on/in:
ProPublica Facebook Twitter Reddit Instagram Someone sent it to me directly An article A ProPublica newsletter Another forum, newsletter, blog, group I subscribe to An SMS/text message survey Other
How do you identify your race/ethnicity? How do you identify your race/ethnicity?
Asian or Asian American Black Hispanic or Latino/a Middle Eastern or North African Native American or Indigenous American Native Hawaiian/Pacific Islander White
Other
Do you have ideas for getting the word out? Who else should we talk to?
Saved
Powered by Screendoor.
Measure
Measure